Simms Steps Up

MINNEAPOLIS – For the second time in three years, the Wisconsin women’s hockey team is the national champion, and the main reason why is Kirsten Simms.  

Simms scored on a penalty shot with 18 seconds left in the third period Sunday to tie the game against Ohio State, and then at the 2:49 mark in overtime, she scored on a rebound to give the Badgers a 4-3 victory and its eighth national title.  

There was a video clip on social media that showed Badgers head coach Mark Johnson on the bench asking who wanted to take the penalty shot and Simms’ hand went up right away. 

“I can’t really say it was initially my choice,” Simms said with a laugh. “I had everyone on the bench screaming ‘Simms, you do it,’ so I was like ‘You know what, whatever.’ Coach is going to need to see my hand go up for me to actually go. After that, everyone just really instills confidence within me, and I actually have to thank all my teammates for that because I was super nervous going into that moment, obviously. But they all calmed me down and reminded me to just be confident in what I do and what I decide to do, and it (ended up) working out for us.” 

When asked about that video clip, Johnson talked about the mentality needed to be able to score on a penalty shot in that crucial of a situation. 

“Most (people) don’t want to go out there and embarrass themselves,” he said. “I’ve had players that don’t want to take penalty shots even though they were awarded one because they’re thinking negatively. They think they’re going to miss it. If you’re lining up for your birdie putt and you think you’re going to miss it, you’re probably going to miss it. I wanted to see who wanted to step up and own it. Who felt comfortable in the setting, because you can’t have one ounce of negativity in your mind as you pick the puck up. It’s got to be all positive, because if you think about what’s going on, you’re going to miss your putt and you’re going to miss the shot. That’s what the ultimate pressure in our game is about, and you can’t get any more pressure than that. 3-2, you’re down, national championship game. If you miss, the game is probably over other than maybe we get something off a faceoff on the power play.

“Laila (Edwards) came back, she was adamant that their player had their glove on the puck inside the crease, which your team is awarded a penalty shot. Then it comes down to who wants to step up. So, a couple players mentioned Kirsten and then the ownership is hers. ‘I’ll take it.’ ‘Okay, go get it.’

“I looked away. I didn’t even watch. I was like (goalie) Ava (McNaughton). I was asking several people after. I don’t know if I was playing, I would take the shot just because you’ve got to be as free as you can be right in that moment. You can’t be thinking about anything other than I’m going to score.” 

Familiar foes in the national title game
This was the third year in a row where Wisco faced OSU for the national title. After coming up short last year, the Badgers got the job done this time around. The Badgers also finished the season with a stellar record of 38-1-2, with the only loss coming against the Buckeyes back in November.  

“Obviously, we found a way to win,” Johnson said. “I don’t think we played one of our better games, but as I told the team a few minutes ago, we figured out how to get to the finish line. I’ve always said Monday always comes. Well, Monday’s coming tomorrow, and we’ve got the national championship trophy back in Madtown. So, it’s a good day.” 

While the Badgers were celebrating, the Buckeyes were visibly distraught with a few players lying face down on the ice and attempting to come to grips with what just happened as they were just seconds away from back-to-back national titles and their third overall in program history.  

“There’s not a lot to really say after a tough loss,” said OSU coach Nadine Muzerall. “Fantastic human beings (her players). I thought they played phenomenal tonight. I think it was just more of the way we lost, with 18 seconds left. It was just an unfortunate outcome. A debatable penalty shot, hard to challenge it when we’d already used our timeout. Very exciting hockey game though.” 

When asked about Simms’ penalty shot, which came because OSU’s Maddi Wheeler covered the puck with her hand in the crease, Muzerall explained what the officials told her after a video review. 

“The covering of the puck, she (the referee) just said she (Wheeler) had her hand covering it,” Muzerall said. “It’s not like she just swatted it away. She actually put her hand over it, and then you kind of lost sight of it because it went under her. I get that it was a penalty shot. I just question the actual penalty shot. And we didn’t have enough proof to rule against it in that quick moment. But we were contemplating if the puck moved back on her penalty shot, and I already used a timeout, so I didn’t want to go down, possibly 6-on-3.” 

The first period was a tight one throughout as both teams generated decent chances early on, but made some key defensive plays near the net to keep it at 0-0. The Buckeyes got on the scoreboard first thanks to a great individual effort by Joy Dunne. With OSU trying to kill a penalty, the sophomore zoomed past three Wisconsin players and deked out McNaughton for a shorthanded goal to make it 1-0 at the 8:22 mark.

However, just 12 seconds later, Wisco cashed in on its power play as Edwards did almost the same thing to Buckeyes goalie Amanda Thiele, beating her to the left post, just before a diving OSU player could knocked the puck away.  

OSU answered back though as Sloane Matthews skated into the Badgers zone along the far boards and beat McNaughton top shelf to put the Buckeyes back up 2-1 at 14:44. The Buckeyes would maintain that slim lead going into the second.  

Just 10 seconds into the second, the Buckeyes struck again. OSU’s Makenna Webster skated around the Badgers net and tried to feed Jocelyn Amos in front, but the puck deflected out to a waiting Emma Peschel, who blasted a shot past McNaughton to make it 3-1 Buckeyes.

Wisco wouldn’t go away though. At 5:27, the Badgers’ Caroline Harvey trimmed the deficit to one goal. Harvey got a pass across the slot from Simms and sniped it past Thiele to make it 3-2 heading into the third.  

After struggling to get good chances throughout the last period of regulation, the Badgers got a great one in the last 1:50 as the Buckeyes were whistled for too many skaters. With McNaughton on the bench for the extra attacker, Wheeler committed her penalty, Simms was given a penalty shot and she buried it to tie things up at 3-3 and force overtime.